The review format is in development. RNA Forecast is not accepting review commissions at this stage. Details will be published when the format launches.
An RNA structure review will be scientific work. It will evaluate computational results with the published methods of the field and be written by Michael T. Wolfinger, co-developer of the ViennaRNA Package, who has worked on RNA structure and its interpretation since 2000.
The planned format is a commissioned assessment for a defined question. It will not be a collaboration and will carry no co-authorship. The group will keep the document and its results. Scope, terms and availability will be published when the format launches.
What a wrong structure costs a project, worked through on real sequences, is in What a wrong RNA structure costs.
What a review will contain
A written document on the sequence or the set of sequences in question, which will state for the question asked
- which helices of the predicted structure are supported, and by what, i.e. base pair probabilities, ensemble diversity, suboptimal structures, conservation where homologues exist, probing data where there are any
- where the ensemble disagrees with the single structure in the figure, and whether that disagreement touches the region the question is about
- what the model does not contain for this molecule, e.g. modified nucleotides, ions, proteins, tertiary contacts, and whether that matters for the decision at hand
- which observation would contradict the interpretation, so that the next experiment is chosen to settle something
- the methods and software versions, named as in a methods section, so that the assessment can be cited
When a review will be worth it. Before modified mRNAs go to synthesis. Before a mutant series designed against a helix. Before a structure figure goes into a manuscript or a grant application. When probing data and prediction disagree. When a design has to keep its structure under sequence changes.
What it will not be. Tertiary structure prediction, wet-lab work, project management, or a promise about how the molecule behaves in a cell. A review will say how far the computation carries the question and where the evidence has to come from somewhere else.
Groups that would rather learn to do this themselves will find the same questions in ViennaRNA training from the developers.